The Real War on Christmas

Maybe you have heard of “Cupgate 2015”? Or maybe you have been lucky enough to avoid the social media frenzy? At any rate, it seems consumers are up in arms over Starbucks purportedly trying to “take Christ out of Christmas” by not having festive enough cups this holiday season. All evidence of the WAR ON CHRISTMAS, as many are quick to proclaim.

(Photo: Karen Bleier , AFP/Getty Images)

My first thought: Is it really the “Holiday Season” already? I have hardly taken down my Halloween décor (OK- let’s be real. Mama is in survival-mode with 9 month old twins, a 6 year old, and a full-time job. There was no Halloween décor. That is not the point). The Christmas creep, and the “War on Christmas Creep” as it were, continues to come earlier and earlier. Just ask Slate.

If you had asked me 4 years ago if I thought there was such a thing as a War on Christmas my agnostic, cynical self would have scoffed at your ridiculous question. Of course there is no War on Christmas. Christians are in the majority in this country and Christian holidays are the norm. I am convinced now that is not the case. There is a War on Christmas. But, it is not what you think it is. It is not in Starbuck’s red cups. It is not in people offering you a “Happy Holidays” greeting instead of a “Merry Christmas” greeting. Oh no.

The real “War on Christmas” is much sneakier than that. However, those things are casualties of the war in some ways, and Screwtape would be pleased.

Just this morning, as I sipped my (home brewed) coffee and plotted out my day off in which I must do-all-the-things, I caught a bit on the news about tricks for scoring the best deals on the hottest stuff. The host was presenting the information to “smart, savvy, shoppers” and the presenter was being lauded for her insider tips. Mere minutes later I caught a blurb about how some percentage of parents admitted they would behave unethically to get the last hot item on the shelf. Maybe that makes you laugh, or shake your head in disbelief. Or maybe you are not surprised in the slightest. Because, that is what Christmas is about. Christmas is about getting stuff. Christmas is about consumerism and materialism and keeping up with the Joneses. I mean, look at how bent out of shape people are over the decorations on their $5 cup of coffee.

How misplaced is our distain? As Christians, Christmas is about celebrating the birth of our Savior. The miracle of the Incarnation, of God becoming Man. Or, as written so beautifully in this article from Catholic Courier:

…our loving God gave us the greatest gift possible: his own Son. God gave us a savior, the Prince of Peace, the promise of eternal life — and all the wisdom, peace and comfort the little child Jesus would grow to give us as a very way of life and a pathway to God.

The real war on Christmas is ever permeating consumerism that drives our “throw-away culture”, as Pope Francis often laments. And, the saddest irony is in all the self-identifying Christians who will spend these next few weeks participating in this quest for stuff in the name of “Holiday Cheer”; or, the desire to give their children the “Perfect Christmas” that is defined only in things.

Friends, our lives revolve around stuff. Our houses, our lives, our minds, are cluttered with it. Our personal finances are in dire straits in the pursuit of more of it, in many cases. And for what? Can stuff make us happy?

The real war on Christmas is that people are using so much energy being outraged over a red cup, in the assertion that Christ would somehow be represented more appropriately by the cups being adorned with snowflakes, or Christmas Trees. Shouldn’t we instead focus our energy on being examples of Christ? On feeding the hungry. On clothing the naked. On being a force of love. Or in the very least spending our Christmas season (which hasn’t liturgically started yet!) contemplating the Real Gift, that is that God became Man and dwelt among us (John 1:14), that God so loved the world that he gave his only begotten Son, that whoever believes in Him shall not perish, but have eternal life (John 3:16). And, in becoming Man,  “Christ died for us. Much more then, having now been justified by His blood, we shall be saved from the wrath of God through Him.” (Romans 5:8-9).

If you think about Christ’s birth in the wholeness of Salvation History, in that Christ was born only to die, to shed His Blood for us, red is actually a fitting color for a Christmas cup.


9 thoughts on “The Real War on Christmas

  1. I really love what you’re saying here! I agree; we’re focused way too much on consumerism, and that’s a very serious attack on Christmas – even for devout families. One problem I have with this whole red cup controversy, though, is that I don’t actually know any Christians or Catholics who are actually upset about the red cup thing; a part of me thinks it’s a media campaign 😉 That’s me being skeptical though!


  2. I think marketing team at Starbucks is celebrating all this free press. I wonder if, in the end, sales for them will increase with all this extra exposure they’re getting! But I agree with what you’re saying. My goal this year is to have a quiet holiday season, a simple one, one where we focus on others and living a more giving lifestyle. I hope I can put blinders on to keep out all the noise and commercials and ads so I can accomplish this. It’s no easy task to pull that off in America these days!


  3. Yes, this is 6 months later, but a proud mother lead me to this site. This is a very well written point of view. Have you investigated submitting articles to any type of publication?


      1. My little brother and sister are 8 years younger than me and are twins. I spent a lot of time helping take care of them. So, I can somewhat imagine your busy life. Never give up on your dream. I have read a few of you stories on here. Although, I am not an expert, I think there is talent here.


      2. Thank you. It’s always been something I have wanted to do, but never something I have taken the time to cultivate and craft. Maybe someday, or slowly in the spare minutes.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s